Local Gestures
  • Home
  • Dance
  • Literature
  • Music
  • Cinema
  • Home
  • Dance
  • Literature
  • Music
  • Cinema

Local Gestures

because the personal is cultural

Fields in Motion: A Review

8/3/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
When Joann Kealiinohomoku published “An Anthropologist Looks at Ballet as a Form of Ethnic Dance” over 40 years ago, it caused quite a stir in dance studies. Ballet? Ethnic? It was like someone had finally held up a mirror to white people so they could see themselves instead of assuming they were a normative non-ethnicity.

The article pushed dance scholar Dena Davida (better known in Montreal as the artistic director of Tangente) one step further, as she wondered what the ethnographic project for post-modern and contemporary dance would be. The result is now an anthology exploring the issue from a multitude of perspectives, Fields in Motion: Ethnography in the Worlds of Dance.

The irony is that, because of globalization, white people are becoming a normative non-ethnicity after all. As a consequence, the authors in Fields in Motion sometimes explain experiences that might now be familiar to most, including those who have never even attended a contemporary dance show. Not that all writers or subjects discussed are white, by any means.

In the first section, “Inventing Strategies, Models, and Methods,” authors focus on establishing their methodology. It makes one curious and it would have been interesting to discover what findings their methodology yielded. It might be the nature of the beast (in this case, anthologies), as many of the chapters are the introductions to theses. Still, it might have been better to select subsequent thesis chapters to offer readers some meat, at the risk of losing them a bit along the way.

Some authors (like Anne Cazemajou) understandably rely heavily on description, as most readers do not have access to the object of study. Less acceptable is when writers relying on introspective ethnography become unnecessarily wordy. Michèle Moss writes, “I have always been the happiest, indeed most comfortable, when inquiring with my arms and legs as they manipulate time and space.” “Dancing” would have done just as well, if not better.

In a similar vein, the second section on “Embodying Autoethnographies” is, as can be expected, the least scholarly, as writers (like Priya Thomas) get lost in novelistic descriptions that rarely engender knowledge. It is as though writers (Inka Juslin is another one) believe that, if they focus on the details, they might be able to make the reader forget about the big picture; often, there is none. Thesis statements remain hard to identify, if they are present at all.

Karen Barbour even openly states that she is not concerned with “traditional research expectations of reliability and validity,” (!) which makes it hard to take her essay seriously. Indeed, it reads like a LiveJournal entry as she recounts conversations in detail, when she could have made the same points in fewer words. She references her own writing more than anyone else’s, and it accounts for almost a third of her sources. It’s being self-referential in a way that was popular almost two decades ago. While one can easily understand the value of embodiment to dance research, it does not need to be communicated as an unedited, continuous stream of consciousness.

With the third section, “Examining Creative Processes and Pedagogies,” it finally feels like we are getting somewhere. Pamela Newell and Sylvie Fortin examine the power relationship between choreographer and dancers, and how it affects the creative process and outcome.

In what is probably the best essay in the entire book, “Black Tights and Dance Belts: Constructing a Masculine Identity in a World of Pink Tutus in Corner Brook, Newfoundland,” Candice Pike proves that one does not need to be urban to make a worthwhile contribution to knowledge. She notes how, while male is usually the unmarked gender in society, it becomes the marked one in ballet. By interviewing the men attending a ballet class in a small town in the Maritimes, Pike is able to achieve insights into why the subjects took up ballet (to fulfil their unrealized potential) and about the need to question generalizations.

In the final section, “Revealing Choreographies as Cultural and Spiritual Practices,” Emily Wright offers the most humour with her look at American Protestant dance. With just the right amount of self-consciousness, she writes, “When one hears the phrase ‘American Protestant dance,’ many things may come to mind. Or, perhaps, nothing at all.” Perhaps more naïve is her statement that “Auditions for roles in performances were competitive. This led to frustration, disappointment, and disillusionment for dancers who had a strong desire to worship God through dance but lacked the technical excellence required.” Another personal favourite is when she explains, “A more basic understanding is that a Christian dancer is a dancer who is Christian, or a Christian who dances.” Or both, Wright. Or both.

Fields in Motion: Ethnography in the Worlds of Dance
Dena Davida, editor
486 pp.
Wilfrid Laurier University Press
39.95$

0 Comments

    Sylvain Verstricht

    has an MA in Film Studies and works in contemporary dance. His fiction has appeared in Headlight Anthology, Cactus Heart, and Birkensnake.

    s.verstricht [at] gmail [dot] com

    Categories

    All
    2e Porte à Gauche
    Agora De La Danse
    Ame Henderson
    Andrew Tay
    Annabelle Lopez Ochoa
    Anne Le Beau
    Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker
    Anne Thériault
    Ann Van Den Broek
    Antoine Defoort
    Arthur Harel
    Arts Court
    Audrée Juteau
    Aurelie Pedron
    Austria
    Bain Saint-michel
    Belgium
    Benoit Lachambre
    Best Of
    Biennale De Gigue Contemporaine
    Bjm Danse
    Björn Schmelzer
    Boris Charmatz
    Brazil
    Brian Brooks
    Brigitte Haentjens
    Brigitte Poupart
    British Columbia
    Brooklyn Touring Outfit
    Cabaret Du Mile-End
    Caroline Gravel
    Carol Prieur
    Carte Blanche
    Cas Public
    Catalonia
    Catherine Gaudet
    Catherine Tardif
    Cayetano Soto
    Cecilia Bengolea
    Céline Bonnier
    Celine Signoret
    Centaur Theatre
    Chanti Wadge
    Chiara Frigo
    China
    Chris Haring
    Christian Rizzo
    Cindy Van Acker
    Cinema
    Clara Furey
    Compagnie Flak
    Conservatoire
    Dana Gingras
    Dana Michel
    Dance
    Daniel Léveillé
    Danse Carpe Diem
    Danse Cité
    Danse Danse
    Dany Desjardins
    Dave St Pierre
    David Lynch
    David Rancourt
    Deborah Dunn
    Dena Davida
    Dorian Nuskind Oder
    Ecole De Danse Contemporaine
    Elisabeth Kjeldahl Nilsson
    Emmanuel Jouthe
    England
    English
    Erin Flynn
    Estelle Clareton
    Étienne Lepage
    Evelina Dembacke
    Evenko
    Festival TransAmériques
    Finland
    Francais
    France
    Francis Ducharme
    François Chaignaud
    Frederick Gravel
    Fringe
    Gabrielle Marion Rivard
    Gai Behar
    Galerie De L'UQAM
    Geneviève C. Ferron
    George Stamos
    Gerard Reyes
    Germany
    Grand Poney
    Guilherme Botelho
    Guilherme Garrido
    Guilherme Miotto
    Halory Goerger
    Heine Avdal
    Hélène Blackburn
    Hiroaki Umeda
    Holly Bright
    In Jung-ju
    Institutet
    Interviews
    Isabelle Van Grimde
    Israel
    Italy
    Jacinthe Armstrong
    Jaco Van Dormael
    Jacques Poulin Denis
    James Viveiros
    Jamie Wright
    Jana Jevtovic
    Japan
    Jasper Van Lujik
    Jean Sébastien Lourdais
    Jody Hegel
    Jo Fong
    Jonathan Debrouwer
    José Navas
    Julien Desplantez
    Kaori Seki
    Karine Denault
    Katia Marie Germain
    Katie Ward
    Katya Montaignac
    Korea
    Kristel Van Issum
    (LA)HORDE
    La Sala Rossa
    Laurie Anderson
    Leanne Dyer
    Lee Su Jung
    Lemi Ponifasio
    Lia Rodrigues
    Lise Vachon
    Literature
    Louise Lecavalier
    Lucie Bazzo
    Lucie Mongrain
    Lük Fleury
    Maguy Marin
    Mai
    Maïgwenn Desbois
    Maki Morishita
    Manuel Roque
    Marc Boivin
    Margie Gillis
    Maria Kefirova
    Marie Béland
    Marie Brassard
    Marie Chouinard
    Marie Hélène Falcon
    Marilyne St Sauveur
    Marine Brutti
    Markus öhrn
    Marlene Monteiro Freitas
    Marteen Van Der Put
    Martin Messier
    Maryse Damecour
    Mary St-Amand Williamson
    Matija Ferlin
    Mau
    Mauro Bigonzetti
    Meg Stuart
    Mélanie Demers
    Michael Trent
    Michèle Anne De Mey
    Michèle Febvre
    Miguel Gutierrez
    Montréal Arts Interculturels
    Montréal Danse
    Montréal Nouvelles Musiques
    Monument National
    Music
    Nancy Gloutnez
    Natalie Zoey-gauld
    Netherlands
    New Zealand
    Nicolas Cantin
    Norway
    Nova Scotia
    Nya Rampen
    Offta
    Ohad Naharin
    Oh! My Life Movement Theater
    Olivier Arseneault
    Olivier Dubois
    Ontario
    Pamela Poulin
    Park Young-cool
    Patrick Lloyd Brennan
    Pauline Roelants
    Performance Art
    Perrine Valli
    Peter Trosztmer
    Philippe Meunier
    Pierre Lecours
    Pieter Ampe
    Piss In The Pool
    Place Des Arts
    Portugal
    Previews
    Quebec
    Rachel Harris
    Rachid Ouramdane
    Rebecca Halls
    Reviews
    Robyn Orlin
    Sarah Bronsard
    Sarah Chase
    Sarah Dell
    Sarah Williams
    Sasha Kleinplatz
    Shannon Gillen
    Sharon Eyal
    Simon Grenier Poirier
    Société Des Arts Technologiques
    South Africa
    Spain
    Spoken Word
    Stéphane Guignard
    Studio 303
    Susanna Hood
    Sweden
    Switzerland
    Tamara Bacci
    Tangente
    Tao Ye
    Teilo Troncy
    Teita Iwabuchi
    The 605 Collective
    Thea Patterson
    Theatre
    Theatre Jean-Duceppe
    Theatre La Chapelle
    The Choreographers
    Thirst/Clarity
    Trajal Harrell
    T.r.a.s.h.
    United States
    Usine C
    Videos
    Virginie Brunelle
    Visual Arts
    Wales
    Wants&needs Danse
    Wayne Mcgregor
    Wildside Festival
    Yukiko Shinozaki
    Zohar Melinek

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly